4softhr vs Smartree: self-service HR software vs outsourcing

4softhr and Smartree are both HR players in Romania, but with different models. 4softhr (part of the 4b2b ecosystem) is self-service HR software: employee records, leave, payroll with gross-to-net calculation and recruiting with manual statuses, with a free Start plan for 12 months and no card — you keep control in-house. Smartree is best known for HR outsourcing services (payroll, personnel administration) combined with its own platform, suited to firms that want to delegate these processes entirely.

Updated June 2026

Why 4softhr

  • Self-service software: you keep in-house control of HR data and processes, without outsourcing.
  • Recruiting with job openings, candidates and manually updated statuses.
  • Free Start plan for 12 months, no card required.
  • Records for employees and linked documents, with data stored in the EU, GDPR-compliant.
  • Fast, self-serve onboarding — go live in days, without a complex service contract.
  • Part of the 4b2b ecosystem, with a single account across 4b2b products.

Where the alternative may fit better

  • Smartree offers full payroll and personnel-admin outsourcing — they take over the process, which 4softhr does not (it is software, not a service).
  • For firms that want to fully delegate HR and payroll, Smartree's service model is a better fit.
  • Smartree has payroll and outsourced personnel-process expertise built over years of serving large clients.
  • 4softhr calculates gross-to-net with configurable parameters but does not file D112, does not submit to REGES-ONLINE and does not offer services run by an external team.

Short verdict

Choose 4softhr if you want self-service HR software, a free Start plan and in-house control of your data. Choose Smartree if you want to fully outsource payroll and personnel administration to a specialised team.

Side-by-side comparison

Criterion4softhrSmartree
ModelSelf-service HR software (SaaS)HR outsourcing + own platform
In-house control vs delegationYou keep HR processes in-houseYou can delegate payroll/personnel administration
PayrollGross-to-net calculation with configurable parameters and payslips; no D112 filing or REGES submissionPayroll run as an outsourced service
RecruitingJob openings, candidates and manual statuses; no AI CV scoringServices- and platform-led, AI not the focus
Employee records / REGESEmployee and document records; no REGES-ONLINE submissionCovered through services; check with the vendor
Pricing / segmentFree Start plan for 12 months, no cardTypically priced per service / volume
RolloutSelf-serve, go live in daysService contract + assisted setup
Ecosystem & integrations4b2b: one account across 4b2b productsOwn platform + HR services

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between 4softhr and Smartree?
4softhr is self-service HR software where you keep in-house control; Smartree is known above all for outsourcing payroll and personnel administration as a service.
Does 4softhr run payroll for me, like Smartree?
Partly. 4softhr calculates gross-to-net with configurable parameters and issues payslips, but does not run payroll as an outsourced service or file D112 — outsourcing is Smartree's strength.
Which platform fits better if I want to keep HR in-house?
4softhr: self-service software with a free Start plan for 12 months, without outsourcing your processes.
Are both compliant with Romanian labour law?
4softhr does not submit to REGES-ONLINE; that step is done separately. Smartree handles compliance through its own services and platform.
When is Smartree the better choice?
When you want to fully delegate payroll and personnel administration to a specialised external team, Smartree's outsourcing model is a better fit.