What is a personal grievance in New Zealand and how should employers respond?
Short answer
- A personal grievance is a formal complaint by an employee, for example unjustified dismissal, unjustified disadvantage, discrimination, harassment or a breach of an employment agreement.
- The employee must raise the grievance with the employer within 90 days of the action, or of becoming aware of it, and the employer must respond.
- Most disputes go to mediation through Employment New Zealand, then to the Employment Relations Authority if not resolved.
- The test for a dismissal is whether the employer’s actions and how they acted were what a fair and reasonable employer could have done.
What the law says
- Employment Relations Act 2000, section 103: lists the grounds for a personal grievance.
- Section 114: the employee must raise a grievance within 90 days; the employer can agree to a longer time or the Authority can allow an extension in limited cases.
- Section 103A: the test of justification for dismissal and disadvantage, including investigation, raising concerns and a genuine opportunity to respond.
- Remedies under section 123 can include reinstatement, reimbursement of lost wages, and compensation for humiliation, loss of dignity and injury to feelings.
- The Employment Relations Amendment Act 2026 introduced an income threshold for dismissal grievances for high earners ($200,000 total remuneration with a transition for existing agreements); confirm the detail on employment.govt.nz.
Practical examples
- A worker dismissed without a warning or a chance to respond may claim lost wages, for example 13 weeks at $1,000 a week equals $13,000, plus compensation.
- An employer who runs a fair process, notes the concerns, offers a meeting and allows a support person has a much stronger position.
- A mediator’s settlement of $4,500 is recorded in writing and signed, which brings the claim to an end.
- A manager who removes an employee’s regular hours without consultation could face an unjustified disadvantage claim.
Common mistakes
- Dismissing on the spot without investigating, giving a chance to respond or considering the employee’s explanation.
- Ignoring a letter raising a grievance, which can cost the employer the chance to settle early.
- Not keeping dated records of conversations, warnings and performance meetings.
- Telling the employee that they cannot bring a claim simply because they are in a trial period or a small business.
How 4softhr helps
- Employee records and notes to keep dated documentation of role changes, positions and departments.
- Offboarding tasks to complete exit steps consistently, such as returning equipment and final pay checks.
- Leave requests and balances give a clear history of approved leave.
- 4softhr is not a legal tool and does not give legal advice; talk to a lawyer or Employment New Zealand for individual cases.