How do you dismiss an employee fairly in South Africa and what happens at the CCMA?
Short answer
- A dismissal is fair only if the reason is fair (misconduct, incapacity or operational requirements) and the procedure is fair.
- The employee should be told the allegations, given time to prepare and a chance to respond, usually in a hearing.
- A dismissed employee can refer the dispute to the CCMA within 30 days of the dismissal.
- If a dismissal is found unfair, the employer may have to reinstate or pay compensation of up to 12 months’ pay.
What the law says
- Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 sections 188 and 189: a dismissal must be for a fair reason and follow a fair procedure.
- The Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, issued in 2025, replaced the old Schedule 8 and guides what a fair process looks like; read the current text on labour.gov.za.
- Section 191: referral to the CCMA within 30 days of the date of dismissal; unfair labour practice disputes within 90 days.
- Section 194: compensation for an unfair dismissal is capped at 12 months’ remuneration, and 24 months for an automatically unfair dismissal.
- Section 187: dismissals for pregnancy, trade union activity or asserting rights are automatically unfair.
Practical examples
- An employee on R15,000 a month is dismissed unfairly: compensation up to 12 x R15,000 = R180,000.
- An employee is dismissed on 3 March: the CCMA referral deadline is 30 days later; a late referral needs condonation.
- A first minor warning-level offence is met with dismissal: likely unfair; progressive discipline applies.
- An employee fails to meet agreed performance standards after support and warnings: dismissal for poor performance can be fair.
Common mistakes
- Dismissing before holding a hearing or giving the employee a chance to respond.
- Relying on an unsigned or unwritten rule that staff never saw.
- Treating all misconduct the same instead of applying the disciplinary code consistently.
- Not keeping the records, notice of hearing and minutes that you need at the CCMA.
How 4softhr helps
- Employee records and organisation structure so each person’s role and manager are clear.
- Departments, positions and organisation chart to show reporting lines.
- Notifications through 4notify to remind managers of hearing dates.
- 4softhr does not generate contracts, legal letters or e-signatures.