How does retrenchment work in South Africa under section 189?
Short answer
- Retrenchment is a dismissal for operational requirements, which means economic, technological, structural or similar needs of the business.
- Before dismissing, the employer must consult the affected employees or their union to try to avoid, reduce or soften the retrenchments.
- You must issue a written notice with the reasons, alternatives considered, selection criteria, severance pay offered and the number of employees affected.
- Large employers use a facilitated process under section 189A; most small employers follow section 189.
What the law says
- Labour Relations Act section 189: a duty to consult and to disclose relevant information in writing.
- Section 189A: additional rules, a 60-day period and the right to strike or refer to the Labour Court, for larger employers and large-scale retrenchments; check the size thresholds in the Act.
- Selection criteria must be agreed or, failing that, fair and objective.
- BCEA section 41: at least one week of severance pay for each completed year of service.
- Employees dismissed for operational reasons can dispute fairness at the CCMA or Labour Court; the process is a main point of attack.
Practical examples
- A business with 20 employees loses its main client and must cut 3 posts: it issues section 189(3) notices and holds consultation meetings first.
- Selection by “last in, first out” with a reasonable exception for scarce skills is a common fair criterion.
- An employee with 4 years of service and weekly pay of R3,000: severance 4 x R3,000 = R12,000, plus notice and leave.
- The employer offers a vacant role at the same salary to an affected employee, which reduces the dismissals.
Common mistakes
- Deciding who goes before any consultation, so the meetings are only a formality.
- Retrenching someone and hiring a replacement in the same role a few weeks later.
- Using retrenchment to remove a poor performer, which is a dishonest reason.
- Giving information late or only orally, instead of the written section 189(3) notice.
How 4softhr helps
- Employee records, departments, positions and the org chart to map affected roles.
- Leave balances per employee, so you can calculate the leave payout correctly.
- Payroll with a configurable gross-to-net calculation for final payslips with severance.
- 4softhr does not provide legal advice or lodge anything at the CCMA.