Retrenchment-section-189

How does retrenchment work in South Africa under section 189?

Short answer

  1. Retrenchment is a dismissal for operational requirements, which means economic, technological, structural or similar needs of the business.
  2. Before dismissing, the employer must consult the affected employees or their union to try to avoid, reduce or soften the retrenchments.
  3. You must issue a written notice with the reasons, alternatives considered, selection criteria, severance pay offered and the number of employees affected.
  4. Large employers use a facilitated process under section 189A; most small employers follow section 189.

What the law says

  • Labour Relations Act section 189: a duty to consult and to disclose relevant information in writing.
  • Section 189A: additional rules, a 60-day period and the right to strike or refer to the Labour Court, for larger employers and large-scale retrenchments; check the size thresholds in the Act.
  • Selection criteria must be agreed or, failing that, fair and objective.
  • BCEA section 41: at least one week of severance pay for each completed year of service.
  • Employees dismissed for operational reasons can dispute fairness at the CCMA or Labour Court; the process is a main point of attack.

Practical examples

  • A business with 20 employees loses its main client and must cut 3 posts: it issues section 189(3) notices and holds consultation meetings first.
  • Selection by “last in, first out” with a reasonable exception for scarce skills is a common fair criterion.
  • An employee with 4 years of service and weekly pay of R3,000: severance 4 x R3,000 = R12,000, plus notice and leave.
  • The employer offers a vacant role at the same salary to an affected employee, which reduces the dismissals.

Common mistakes

  • Deciding who goes before any consultation, so the meetings are only a formality.
  • Retrenching someone and hiring a replacement in the same role a few weeks later.
  • Using retrenchment to remove a poor performer, which is a dishonest reason.
  • Giving information late or only orally, instead of the written section 189(3) notice.

How 4softhr helps

  • Employee records, departments, positions and the org chart to map affected roles.
  • Leave balances per employee, so you can calculate the leave payout correctly.
  • Payroll with a configurable gross-to-net calculation for final payslips with severance.
  • 4softhr does not provide legal advice or lodge anything at the CCMA.
4b2b.net
Business Ecosystem
4conta.ro
Accounting
4invoices.net
Invoicing App
4expenses.net
Expense Management
4notify.net
Notifications
4hosting.net
Hosting
4database.net
Databases
4buildsite.net
Website Builder
4myapp.net
App Builder
4avatars.net
AI Avatars
4chaty.net
AI Chatbot
4webagency.net
Web Agency Software
4softedu.net
Education Websites
4softcrm.net
CRM Platform
4softerp.net
ERP System
4softhr.net
HR Management
4mystaff.net
Staff Portal
4myprojects.net
Project Manager
4mycontracts.net
Contracts
4docs.net
Document Management
4appointments.net
Appointments
4marketingonline.net
Marketing
4insurance.net
Insurance
4property.net
Real Estate
4lawyers.net
Legal Software
4mygarage.net
Auto Service
4driving.net
Driving Schools
4fleet.net
Fleet Management
4myevents.net
Events
4therapy.net
Therapy
4clinics.net
Clinics
4dental.net
Dental Practices
4restaurants.net
Restaurants
4beautify.net
Beauty Salon
4gym.net
Fitness Gyms
4guards.net
Security Companies
4softvet.net
Veterinary Clinics
4softauto.net
Automotive Business Software
4construct.net
Construction Companies
4marketplace.net
Marketplace
4shopy.net
Online Store
4pricing.net
Price Comparison
4salefood.net
Food Delivery
4rentify.net
Rentals
4transports.net
Transport
4agencytravel.net
Travel Agency
4hotel.net
Hotel Management
4ong.net
NGO Management